Print Page | Contact Us | Sign In | Join or Renew
The FTRF Blog
Blog Home All Blogs
Read the latest news about FTRF and the First Amendment in Libraries and engage with thoughtful opinions from leaders in our community on The FTRF Blog.

 

Search all posts for:   

 

Top tags: Banned Books Week  Judith Krug Memorial Fund  FTRF45  membership  BBW2014  banned books  Conable Scholarship  litigation  Roll of Honor  Media Coalition  special events  ALA Annual Conference  Barbara Jones  Board of Trustees  Carolyn Forsman  election  givingfREADom  GivingTuesday  grants  Judith Krug remembrances  Midwinter Meeting  Theresa Chmara  ALA  Annual Conference  censorship  Emily Knox  FTRF News  online learning  ACLU  Banned Websites Awareness Day 

FTRF Reception this Friday in Kansas City

Posted By Jonathan M. Kelley, Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Those attending the Joint Conference of Librarians of Color conference this week - and anyone in the Kansas City area - please join the Freedom to Read Foundation at a reception on Friday from 6-7:00 p.m. at the Westin Crown Center, 1 East Pershing Road in Kansas City, MO in the Roanoke Foyer.

You don't have to be a member to stop by, relax, have a nosh, chat with friends, and learn more about the work FTRF is doing to protect the freedom to read!

Following the reception, we also invite you to attend the 50 for Freedom of Speech event in the adjacent Shawnee Mission room.  FTRF is pleased to cosponsor  - with REFORMA and Librotraficante - this celebration of Mexican American and Ethnic Studies literature and the freedom to read.  The event is one of many around the country responding to the dismantling earlier this year of the Tucson Unified School District's Mexican American Studies Program and the concomitant removal of books from all district classrooms.

Tags:  JCLC  reception  Reforma  special events 

Share |
PermalinkComments (0)
 

Welcome to FTRF's new home!

Posted By Jonathan M. Kelley, Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Welcome!  Today marks the official unveiling of the new new Freedom to Read Foundation website. We have worked for months to build a place that our members (and soon-to-be members) can come and participate on multiple levels.  The site will make it easier for you to manage your contact information, learn about the activities and events of the Foundation, and help us toward our mission of defending the right to provide and access information.

Among the features:

This new site is a key goal of our strategic plan, and it's our hope that it will assist us as we seek to build FTRF's membership, profile, and successful litigation and education efforts.  With any new site, we're still testing things out, and your feedback is strongly encouraged - just drop us a line at ftrf@ala.org with suggestions, critiques, or questions.

Again, welcome!  We hope you enjoy the new site ... and will help us spread the word about the Freedom to Read Foundation.

P.S. If you're not yet a member, or haven't been a member in some years, we hope you'll consider joining the Freedom to Read Foundation today!  If you're a current or recent member and would like to review your contact information or check the status of your membership, please contact me at jokelley@ala.org (or check your email this week for login instructions).

Tags:  Freedom to Read Foundation  members  website 

Share |
PermalinkComments (0)
 

Theresa Chmara discusses recent filtering decisions

Posted By Jonathan M. Kelley, Wednesday, August 1, 2012
Updated: Thursday, August 2, 2012

Theresa ChmaraFreedom to Read Foundation General Counsel Theresa Chmara has written an article for American Libraries magazine discussing recent court decisions in Washington and Missouri affecting Internet filtering in libraries:

Why Recent Court Decisions Don’t Change the Rules on Filtering

Several libraries have been sued recently on the grounds that their internet filtering programs are unconstitutional, raising questions in the library community about whether the rules have changed about blocking software.

The short answer is no.

In discussing a federal judge's recent decision in the case Bradburn v. North Central Regional Library, Chmara explained that:

The fact that the district court in one case upheld an internet filtering system does not mean that other libraries can be assured of a similar result.

In another recent case involving a school library, the US District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri reached a different conclusion. The court held on February 15 that the school district in Camdenton, Missouri, had unconstitutionally blocked websites that support or advocate on behalf of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people while permitting students access to websites that condemn homosexuality or oppose legal protections for LGBT people.

In that case, the district had to pay significant legal expenses.  Chmara concludes by noting:

If libraries use filters that block constitutionally protected material deemed harmful to minors and do not allow adults to disable filters, or fail to provide an effective unblocking system, those libraries may open the door to years of litigation and significant legal expenses.

We encourage everyone interested in this issue to read the entire article (plus Chmara's follow-up comment) at American Libraries.  As she points out, neither the article nor the comment are intended as legal opinions, and libraries should consult their legal counsel regarding their particular situation.

Tags:  CIPA  filtering  Theresa Chmara 

Share |
PermalinkComments (0)
 

From Here to Expurgation

Posted By Barbara Jones, FTRF Executive Director, Friday, July 20, 2012

This article was originally printed in the October 2011 issue of FTRF News. 

Ask any curator of literary manuscripts, and they will tell you how extensively some manuscripts are edited before publishing. Often the editing process catches factual errors or reins in verbose writers. Maxwell Perkins, a renowned U.S. literary editor, engaged in painful negotiations with Thomas Wolfe and persuaded him to cut over 50,000 words from Look Homeward, Angel. While it destroyed their friendship, critics agree that a better novel emerged.

But there are also instances of editing that constitute censorship: the intentional expurgation of words or topics feared to cause government censorship or public outcry. Expurgation can happen before or after publication. Of recent notoriety is a 2011 edition of Huckleberry Finn published by NewSouth Books, in which editor Alan Gribben replaced all instances of the word "nigger” with "slave.”

In the 1950’s, James Jones’s manuscript for From Here to Eternity was expurgated by his publisher, Charles Scribner’s Sons. According to daughter Kaylie Jones, also an author, all publishers were walking a fine line in that era. Before the famous Supreme Court obscenity trials starting in 1957, the U.S. Post Office acted prominently as a watchdog. Scribner’s alerted James Jones that they were going to excise the word "fuck” as much as possible, hoping that the published book would pass Post Office muster. (There are 36 "fuck”s in the 1951 edition.) There is no record of editor’s instructions regarding the gay- themed passages, but they were expurgated.

This 1951 best seller won the National Book Award, and the 1953 film garnered eight Academy Awards. Eternity is based on Jones’s experiences in the U.S. Army infantry—a group of soldiers serving in Hawaii before and during the attack on Pearl Harbor. Jones wanted to capture the life of the "ordinary” foot soldier—off duty drinking, boxing, playing cards, and cavorting with women. The book ends with the attack on Schofield Barracks on December 7, 1941. The book’s authenticity required barracks language and homosexual activity and references.

Like all censorship, there is historical context to the publication of Eternity. After World War II, the U.S. attempted to manipulate media of all types to frame the war as "total victory.” Film director and soldier John Ford was hired by the Army to shoot documentaries at the D-Day landing, and about such topics as PTSD. But then the Army suppressed them. They wanted a happy and noble ending. Homosexual activity, trauma, and salty language were not part of that vision.

When I worked at the University of Illinois, I used to look at their Jones Eternity manuscript and shiver to read the author’s pleading marginalia: "This needs to stay.” "Surely this is not censorable.” "Why can’t you leave this in if ‘the word’ is changed”? ("The word” is "fuck.”)


An original page from James Jones’s manuscript for From Here to Eternity, reprinted with permission of the Rare Book and Special Collections Library, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

In 2009, Kaylie Jones and her brother became the executors of their father’s estate. She revealed the expurgations, including gay references, and decided they needed to be restored in a new edition.

As she told The Guardian: "James Jones believed that homosexuality... in no way affected a soldier’s capability in the battlefield ... we think it’s relevant given the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell controversy.”

Happily as a result of Ms. Jones’s perseverance, the unexpurgated Eternity was published in May 2011 by Open Road Media, an e-book publisher. It is titled From Here to Eternity: The Restored Edition.

According to Robert Doyle’s Banned Books: Challenging the Freedom to Read, the book was removed from two libraries and, despite Scribner’s best attempts, the New York City Post Office banned it from the mails in 1955.

Only when advocates like Kaylie Jones take a passionate interest in the author’s original words, will these books be restored. Imagine how many lie in manuscript libraries right now—victims of fear.

Tags:  Barbara Jones  expurgation  From Here to Eternity  James Jones 

Share |
PermalinkComments (0)
 

The Sanitation of Mark Twain

Posted By Kent Oliver, Immediate Past President, Friday, July 20, 2012
Updated: Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Mark Twain’s book The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, first published in 1884, is one of America’s literary masterpieces. A recent edition conceived by Alan Gribben, professor of English at Auburn University and Twain scholar, has been edited to remove racially charged words. This edition clearly subverts the intent of the author: depicting life on the Mississippi River in the 1800s. It contributes to a disturbing trend in our society to dumb down controversial ideas, subjects and language in our literature. An exhaustive list of titles and topics demonstrating this practice may be found at www.ala.org/ala/issuesadvocacy.

Because of its language and surface racism, Huck Finn has often been the target of book challenges and bannings. Ironically, the book is highly regarded in part because of its undeniable anti-racism message. Any deviation from the original is a desecration of the author’s work and original intent. Mr. Twain himself was very particular about the words he used and why. According to an oft- used quote by the author, "the difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter—it’s the difference between the lightning bug and the lightning.” Possibly foreseeing a challenge to his "right words” such as Professor Gribben’s, Twain was famously concerned over copyright laws and desired to control his works, including his autobiography, beyond the grave.

While there is certainly a place for comfortable literature that entertains, the appeal and great impact of Huck Finn today lies in the fact it does not always make us feel comfortable—not with late-1800s America or with that of 2011. Its power is in the use of uncomfortable words and an insight into a time period that gives us pause for serious reflection.

The American Library Association’s Office for Intellectual Freedom and the Freedom to Read Foundation, along with thousands of librarians and information professionals, support the premise that the most dangerous idea is the suppressed idea. As a society we should be committed to the right of unrestricted access to information and ideas, regardless of the viewpoints of the author or the reader. Without this commitment we run the risk of rewriting history as well as great literature. Students have heard the words; let them read and understand the ideas that go with them.

This article by FTRF President Kent Oliver was initially printed in the May 2011 issue of Costco Connection, Costco’ s monthly newsletter, as part of a Point/Counterpoint. Read the entire issue. Reprinted with permission.


Tags:  Huckleberry Finn  Kent Oliver  Mark Twain  racism 

Share |
PermalinkComments (0)
 
Page 30 of 32
 |<   <<   <  25  |  26  |  27  |  28  |  29  |  30  |  31  |  32